A short question
Posted June 26, 2007
on:- In: Books | Humour
- 17 Comments
I’ve occasionally come across news articles or blog posts in which classic authors, traditionally seen as humorous, are deemed not so. Or the person may find the author funny, but not literally, laugh out loud, slap your knee funny. The two who get this more than others (that I’ve seen) are Oscar Wilde and Jane Austen.
The question: am I the only person who finds these two literally, laugh out loud, slap your knee funny? They don’t write slapstick it’s true but come on, who can do the mock-and-take-down more neatly than Austen? Whose characters can be as outrageous and arch and ridiculous as Wilde’s? Let me know I’m not the only one who throws her head back and cackles at the dead fogeys. (Other authors to consider: Blaise Cendrars (for Moravagine anyway), Miguel de Cervantes, Mark Twain (A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court).)
17 Responses to "A short question"
I’ve only read Wilde’s children’s stories and they’re usually tear-jerkers. And I’ve never read Austen. But I usually end up finding something funny in everything I read and if I don’t I usually put it down.
For some reason I laugh a lot reading The Bible and a lot of twentieth century theology. And not in a, “who believes this garbage?” kind of way. There’s just a lot of funny stuff in there.
Cervantes and Twain are definitely laugh out loud funny. I think future electronic editions of their work should include smileys and “LOL!” marks. You know, so the kids know what to do.
Like Dorothy, I rarely laugh aloud while reading. I might think to myself, “Oh, now that’s funny,” and snicker quietly but cracking up is strictly done in company. Even better when it’s at the company’s expense…
You’re definitely not the only one. In fact, I was planning on making my Thursday Thirteen post a list of Wilde quotes. I’ll try to find the funniest quotes possible, just for you!
Add Proust and Beckett to the list of modernist mirth-meisters.
I find Wilde and Austen deliciously funny, and I am quite verbal in my appreciation! About 10 pages into Ulysses, so we’ll see how that goes!
Stephen Leacock cracks me up, and I have found myself laughing at Shakespeare. The only Wilde I’ve ever read was The Picture of Dorian Gray. While I remember enjoying it, I don’t remember it being particularly funny.
At the risk of biasing my results (there seems to be a lot of Austen fans here), On my blog, I just posted another Great Wednesday Compare, pitting Austen against Poe. (Sorry Imani, hope you don’t mind the plug- but seeing you had just mentioned her, I had to bring it up!)
Cheeky yes, but I didn’t laugh out loud.
I’m not surprised that people don’t “get” Austen. The social world she describes is so unlike our own that it takes time to understand what she’s talking about. Sure, she said something about a character that would be cutting nowadays, but was that an insult back then? What about that thing she said that didn’t seem insulting at all, but all the characters were horrified? It’s particularly hard to tell when a character is being declassee because what was boorish to Austen is everyday manners to us. I had to see a film based on one of Austen’s books before I could understand what she was saying. (Fortunately, once you understand her voice, you’re set.)
But… people don’t laugh at Oscar Wilde? His style of wit is very modern–very fashionable, even. He’s snarky. How on earth can someone miss how funny he is?
1 | Heather
June 26, 2007 at 1:29 pm
Miguel, Mark and Jane – I’m with you on the knee slapping. I’ve never mentioned it to anyone as I wasn’t sure it was appropriate! hehe
Sorry I haven’t been around in awhile!!